Avoiding the big cut: A modern approach to hysterectomy
FOR many Jamaican women facing the prospect of a hysterectomy, the most common image that comes to mind is a large incision across the belly and weeks of recovery. But today, there are alternatives. Minimally invasive hysterectomy techniques—through the vagina or small abdominal incisions—can offer faster healing, less pain, and far fewer complications.
And yes, even in Jamaica, these options are becoming more available.
Why have a hysterectomy?
A hysterectomy is the surgical removal of the uterus. It may be recommended for several reasons, including:
•Fibroids causing heavy bleeding or pressure
•Adenomyosis
•Uterine prolapse
•Chronic pelvic pain (in some cases)
•Cancer (in some cases).
While it’s not a decision to be taken lightly, it can be life-changing for women with debilitating symptoms.
The traditional way – and its drawbacks
Most Jamaican women are familiar with the abdominal hysterectomy — a major surgery that requires a large incision, days in hospital, and weeks of rest and recovery. It remains a necessary option in some complex cases, especially when cancer is involved or the uterus is very large.
But for many women, this approach can be avoided.
The minimally invasive options
There are three key alternatives that reduce or eliminate the need for a large belly cut:
1) Vaginal hysterectomy
This is the oldest form of minimally invasive hysterectomy. The uterus is removed entirely through the vaginal canal, with no abdominal incisions.
•Best for cases with smaller wombs
•Less pain and faster recovery than open surgery
•Fewer complications such as bleeding and infections.
2) Laparoscopic hysterectomy
This involves three or four small incisions in the abdomen. A camera and long instruments are used to remove the uterus—sometimes entirely through the vagina or in pieces through the small openings.
•Provides a better view of the pelvis, especially in women with endometriosis or previous surgeries
•Quick recovery (one to two weeks) and low complication rates
•Can be combined with treatment of other conditions at the same time
3) Minilaparotomy
While not technically MIS, this involves a small 5 cm (two inch) incision in the bikini line to carry out the hysterectomy.
•Doesn’t usually require special instruments
•May take longer due to limited access
•Offers similar benefits to laparoscopy in terms of reduced pain and shorter recovery (two to four weeks) compared to open surgery (four to six weeks)
What’s available in the public system?
We are working toward increasing access to minimally invasive hysterectomy, especially for women in the public system.
•Vaginal hysterectomies can be performed in appropriate cases and are a great option when feasible.
•Laparoscopic hysterectomy is not yet routine but is possible in selected cases—particularly when patients can assist with acquiring a few key disposable items.
•Minilaparotomy is surgeon-dependent and may require purchase of some disposables.
•Hysteroscopy can be used to treat certain causes of heavy periods and avoid hysterectomy altogether. This is increasingly available in the public sector, through government-funded programs or privately loaned equipment.
It’s a work in progress, but the foundation is being built.
What you can do as a patient
If you’re being told you need a hysterectomy, ask your doctor:
•“Is a vaginal or laparoscopic approach possible for me?”
•“What are the benefits and recovery time for each option?”
•“Are these options available in the public system or should I consider other locations?”
Not every patient will be a candidate for minimally invasive surgery, but many are—yet never get the option because the assumption is made that open surgery is “just how it’s done.”
Minimally invasive hysterectomy isn’t about taking shortcuts. It’s about offering the safest, most effective option tailored to each woman’s needs and anatomy.
Across Jamaica, we’re working to expand access and educate both patients and healthcare providers. If we can avoid the big cut—and all the risks that come with it—shouldn’t we?
Dr Ryan Halsall, MBBS DMOG FACOG FMAS, is a consultant OBGYN | Minimally Invasive Surgeon. He operates ILAP Medical, Suite 2, 22 Windsor Avenue, Kingston.