Pension fund management: A balancing act
A pension fund is the accumulation of funds over a period of time that is paid out to employees or contributors upon retirement. Funds are invested in the financial markets/capital markets for the long term, mainly in assets such as stocks, bonds, and real estate. The compound interest earned on pension funds can provide substantial income replacement for retirement. Time and compound interest are important in growing pension funds.
But are pension funds earning attractive rates of interest for members and are the assets continuing on a growth path for 2025? Pension funds globally have shown great resilience since the drastic decline in returns for the year 2022. The funds experienced losses of 4 per cent to 22 per cent. In 2023 many pension funds rebounded and showed even stronger growth in 2024. The outlook for 2025 is optimistic. The same is true for pension funds in Jamaica.
Pension funds are designed to offer financial security for retirees; therefore, pension fund managers must effectively balance risk against returns, especially as countries globally contend with meeting the needs of an aging population.
In its Global Top 300 Pension Funds Report for 2024, the Thinking Ahead Institute provides interesting findings on the performance of pension funds globally. It states that the world’s largest pension funds have returned to growth.
In 2023 the assets of the top 300 pension funds increased by 10 per cent in comparison to a decline of 13 per cent in 2022. The 20 largest pension funds grew by 12 per cent in 2023, and the compound annual growth rate (CAGR) for the top 20 pension funds, covering the past 5 years, was 5.4 per cent.
The study drew special attention to the composition and allocation of assets. Of note, the world’s top 20 largest pension funds invest 43.4 per cent of their assets in the stock markets. Thirty per cent of their assets are invested in bonds, while 22 per cent of assets are invested in alternatives and cash. Examples of alternatives are commodities such as oil and gold.
Stocks, though volatile, are necessary for the long-term and exponential growth of pension funds. Bonds offer stable returns for pension funds and balance the stock market risks. Pension fund managers must manage risks and prudently apportion asset mix to ensure sustained growth for the long term. Cash plays a capital preservation role. Interest rates on cash are low. Cash is considered a low-risk investment and does not keep pace with inflation as it loses value with time. Commodities prices are inclined to increase with inflation and therefore provide pension funds with a buffer against inflation.
Let’s examine the Jamaican pension fund scenario. Based on the Financial Services Commission of Jamaica (FSC) Industry Statistics – June 2024, the allocation of stocks and shares represented 29.11 per cent of private pension assets in Jamaica. Government securities represented 20.61 per cent of pension funds invested. Real estate allotment stood at 8.73 per cent. Bonds and debentures were 10.74 per cent of funds invested, and repurchase agreements were 6.21 per cent. Deposits were allotted 2.28 per cent. Promissory notes, commercial paper, and “other investments” completed the pension fund allocation.
Pension funds grew by 0.98 per cent during the June 2024 quarter, with total funds under management reaching $765.44 billion. The FSC encouraged trustees to maintain vigilant oversight of pension funds by ensuring that funds are rebalanced and sufficiently diversified in a manner that aligns investments with market conditions. The protection of members’ pension benefits is paramount.
According to the Statistical Institute of Jamaica (Statin), the inflation rate for the period December 2023 – December 2024 was 5 per cent. The Bank of Jamaica’s inflation target range is 4 per cent to 6 per cent. It is my considered view that pension fund managers in Jamaica should aim at achieving a compound average growth rate, considerably above the Bank of Jamaica inflation target range if pension funds are to be of real value to contributors when they retire.
Employees should be motivated to start contributing to pension plans early. They should be encouraged to contribute the maximum allowed by law. Some senior employees regret that they didn’t make the maximum contributions to their pension funds much earlier in their working years, as they now race against time to secure a meaningful pension.
Time is crucial in managing risks. When employees begin their pension contributions early pension funds can withstand market fluctuations since pension plans are long-term investments. The compound returns, coupled with asset diversification, will result in reduced risks and provide significant growth in the long term. Managing risks and maximising returns are pivotal in securing financial security for retirees.
Grace G McLean is a financial advisor and retirement specialist at BPM Financial Limited. Contact her at gmclean@bpmfinancial or visit the website: www.bpmfinancial.com. She is also a podcaster for Living Above Self. E-mail her at livingaboveself@gmail.com.